top of page

Articles

BY ZSUZSU
Search

Why a Saddle That Fits Standing Still May Not Fit in Motion

11 minutes ago
9 min read

Part 5 of a six-part series exploring hoof balance, saddle fit, and the whole-horse, whole-rider approach.

Have you ever wondered why a saddle can appear to fit a horse beautifully while standing still, yet create problems once the horse begins moving? Perhaps you've checked the balance, wither clearance, and panel contact, and everything seems to be where it should be. But once the horse begins trotting or cantering, the saddle shifts, the rider struggles to remain balanced, or the horse begins showing signs of discomfort.

Naturally, you might question whether the saddle was fitted correctly in the first place. And perhaps it wasn't. But there's another consideration that I believe deserves just as much attention: the horse's back isn't the same shape when it's moving as it is when standing quietly in the aisle.

I've long described the saddle as an adaptor between horse and rider because it must accommodate two bodies that are constantly changing their positions relative to one another. Evaluating the saddle on a stationary horse gives us valuable information about its basic fit, but it cannot tell us everything about how it will function during movement. To understand that, we need to look at what actually happens beneath the saddle.

The Horse's Back Is Anything but Stationary

When a horse moves, its back doesn't simply travel up and down. The thoracolumbar spine undergoes flexion, extension, lateral bending, and axial rotation, with the amount and coordination of these movements varying according to gait, speed, and the individual horse. The muscles surrounding the spine change their activity throughout the stride, while the trunk responds to forces generated by the limbs and the demands of maintaining balance.

All of this means that the surface beneath the saddle is continually changing. The shape of the back, the activity of the muscles, and the way the trunk moves can vary considerably between standing, walking, trotting, and cantering. A saddle that appears to make appropriate contact while the horse is standing may behave quite differently when those structures begin moving.

Research examining equine back dimensions before and after exercise has demonstrated measurable changes in back shape. Other studies using pressure-measuring systems have shown that saddle loading changes with gait and rider position. These findings help explain why static assessment, although essential, cannot provide a complete picture of saddle function.

I find this particularly important when a horse appears comfortable during a fitting appointment but begins showing difficulties once ridden. Rather than assuming the saddle must be correct because it looked appropriate while the horse was standing, we need to observe how it behaves when the horse is actually doing the work for which the saddle is intended.

What Happens Around the Shoulders?

One of the areas I pay particular attention to is the relationship between the saddle and the horse's shoulders. Unlike our shoulder girdle, the horse's forelimb is attached to the trunk primarily through muscles and connective tissues rather than a bony joint. As the forelimb moves forward and backward, the scapula changes position relative to the rib cage, and the surrounding tissues change shape.

This is why checking whether the saddle appears to sit behind the scapula while the horse is standing doesn't necessarily tell us how it will interact with the shoulder during movement. A saddle positioned too far forward, or one whose tree and panels don't accommodate the horse's anatomy, may create pressure or interfere with movement in that region.

Of course, we need to distinguish between a saddle that is restricting movement and a horse that already has difficulty moving freely. Restrictions through the shoulder region, discomfort within the limb, or altered hoof mechanics may also influence forelimb movement. If a horse shortens its stride, we shouldn't automatically assume that the saddle is responsible simply because the change becomes noticeable when ridden.

This is one reason I want to observe the horse moving without a saddle before evaluating what changes when the saddle and rider are introduced. The comparison can provide valuable information about whether the saddle is contributing to a difficulty or whether the horse was already moving asymmetrically.

Saddle Pressure Changes With Every Stride

Pressure beneath a saddle is not constant. It changes throughout the stride as the horse's back moves and the rider's weight shifts. The distribution of those forces depends on saddle design, panel shape, the horse's conformation and movement, the gait, and the rider's position.

A saddle may appear to make even contact while the horse is standing yet develop areas of increased pressure during movement. Conversely, a pressure measurement taken at one moment doesn't necessarily represent what happens throughout an entire stride. This is why pressure-mapping technology can provide useful information, but the measurements need to be interpreted in relation to the horse's movement, the rider, and the saddle itself.

In a 2016 study, Martin and colleagues examined how the rider's position during rising trot influenced pressure beneath the saddle and movement through the horse's back. They found differences between the seated and standing phases, demonstrating that even within the same gait, changes in rider position can influence the mechanical interaction between horse and saddle.

The study involved only three horses, so we shouldn't generalize its findings too broadly. Nevertheless, it illustrates something that makes perfect biomechanical sense: the forces acting beneath a saddle change as the horse and rider move.

A saddle-fitting assessment that considers only the stationary horse cannot reveal all these dynamic relationships.

Fascia, Muscular Restrictions, and the Moving Back

There's another aspect of the horse's movement that I believe deserves consideration: the role of fascia and the restrictions that may develop within the body's connective and muscular tissues.

Fascia forms a three-dimensional network surrounding, supporting, separating, and connecting muscles and other structures throughout the body. Within that network are regions of differing thickness, density, and fiber orientation, some of which form recognizable pathways of connective-tissue continuity. These are sometimes described as fascial or myofascial lines, although they're not separate anatomical ropes running through the body.

I find it more useful to think of fascia as an interconnected web rather than a collection of isolated lines. It participates in transmitting mechanical forces between connected tissues while also allowing muscles and other structures to glide relative to one another. This doesn't mean that a restriction in one location automatically causes a predictable problem somewhere else, but it does give us another reason to consider the body's connective-tissue relationships when evaluating movement.

Restrictions associated with muscular tension, pain, previous injury, or reduced mobility may influence how the horse uses its back beneath the saddle. A horse with limited movement through the thoracic region or restrictions affecting the shoulder or pelvis may not be able to accommodate the saddle and rider as freely as it otherwise could.

Addressing those restrictions through appropriate bodywork, rehabilitation, or veterinary treatment may be essential. But if altered hoof mechanics are contributing to a compensatory movement pattern, the horse may continue experiencing the same mechanical demands after the restrictions have been released. Equally, improving hoof balance doesn't automatically resolve established muscular restrictions or discomfort elsewhere.

This is why I consider hoof care, bodywork, and saddle fitting complementary rather than competing approaches. Each may be addressing a different aspect of the horse's ability to move comfortably.

The Rider Changes Everything

Now consider what happens when we add the rider. A saddle must accommodate two moving bodies, and the rider is far from being a passive passenger. The rider's pelvis, hips, spine, balance, and ability to follow the horse's movement all influence how weight is transmitted through the saddle.

A rider may appear beautifully balanced while sitting quietly, yet begin compensating as soon as the horse moves. Perhaps one hip doesn't follow the movement as freely as the other, the rider collapses through one side of the waist, or the pelvis shifts in response to an asymmetry in the horse's movement. These changes can influence saddle pressure and stability, sometimes without the rider being aware of what's happening.

Research by Gunst and colleagues, involving 80 horse-rider pairs, demonstrated that both horse and rider asymmetries influenced saddle force distribution. The researchers found that leaning to one side increased loading on that side, while collapsing through one hip altered loading on the opposite side.

What makes this particularly interesting is that the relationship can work in both directions. A rider may be compensating for the horse's movement, while the horse may also be responding to the rider's asymmetry. And the saddle itself can influence the rider's ability to maintain an independent, balanced position.

This is why I don't believe we can properly evaluate saddle fit without considering the rider's body. A saddle that appears to fit the horse may still place the rider in a position that interferes with their ability to move freely, potentially influencing the horse in turn.

What I Look for When Evaluating a Saddle in Motion

When evaluating a saddle dynamically, I'm interested in considerably more than whether it remains centered on the horse's back. I want to understand how the horse moves before the saddle is introduced and whether anything changes when the saddle and rider are added.

Does the horse maintain its rhythm and freedom of movement? Are there differences between the left and right sides? Does the saddle remain stable through transitions, turns, and changes of gait? Does the horse appear comfortable, or are there indications that something may be restricting movement?

I'm equally interested in how the rider functions. Can the rider maintain an independent seat without constantly correcting their position? Does the saddle accommodate the rider's anatomy, or does it encourage compensations? Is the rider able to follow the horse's movement freely, or does the saddle place them in a position that makes this difficult?

These observations don't necessarily establish the cause of a problem, but they help us identify what deserves further investigation. A saddle that shifts may be incorrectly fitted, or it may be responding to asymmetrical movement. A horse that shortens its stride may be experiencing saddle discomfort, but the difficulty could also involve hoof mechanics, body restrictions, or pain elsewhere.

Persistent movement asymmetry or suspected pain warrants appropriate veterinary investigation rather than assuming the saddle is responsible.

A Saddle That Fits Today May Need Reassessment Tomorrow

There's one more consideration that I believe horse owners sometimes overlook: the horse we're fitting today may not have the same back shape or movement patterns several months from now.

Conditioning, muscular development, changes in workload, rehabilitation, weight fluctuations, and age can all influence the horse's body. A horse returning to work after time off may change considerably as strength and muscular development improve. A horse recovering from physical restrictions or altered movement patterns may begin using its back differently.

And changes in hoof mechanics, training, or the rider's physical condition may influence how the entire partnership functions.

A saddle that accommodated the horse at one stage may therefore require reassessment as the horse changes. This doesn't mean every change requires a new saddle. Sometimes adjustments are appropriate, and sometimes the saddle continues to function well. But we shouldn't assume that because a saddle fitted correctly at one point, it will necessarily remain appropriate indefinitely.

For me, this is one of the most compelling reasons to view saddle fitting as an ongoing process rather than a single appointment. The horse and rider are continually adapting, developing, and changing, and the saddle needs to accommodate those changes.

Looking Beyond the Stationary Horse

A stationary saddle-fitting assessment is essential, but it tells us only part of what we need to know. We can evaluate the saddle's basic dimensions, balance, panel contact, and clearance, yet still miss important information about how it functions when the horse and rider begin moving.

The real challenge is understanding how the saddle interacts with two bodies whose movement, balance, and physical condition are constantly influencing one another.

Sometimes the saddle itself is the primary problem. Other times, the saddle may be responding to movement patterns originating elsewhere, or several factors may be contributing together.

This is why I consider hoof function, physical restrictions, horse movement, saddle design, and rider biomechanics together rather than treating saddle fit as an isolated issue.

After all, we don't buy saddles so our horses can stand comfortably in them. We buy them so we can ride.

And surely that's where we need to know whether they actually fit.

Research and Further Reading

1. Martin, P., et al. (2016). Effect of the rider position during rising trot on the horse's biomechanics (back and trunk kinematics and pressure under the saddle). Journal of Biomechanics, 49(7), 1027–1033.

2. Gunst, S., et al. (2019). Influence of Functional Rider and Horse Asymmetries on Saddle Force Distribution During Stance and in Sitting Trot. Journal of Equine Veterinary Science, 78, 20–28.

3. Greve, L., & Dyson, S. (2013). The horse–saddle–rider interaction. The Veterinary Journal, 195(3), 275–281.

4. Greve, L., & Dyson, S. (2013). The interrelationship of lameness, saddle slip and back shape in the general sports horse population. The Veterinary Journal, 195(3), 291–297.

5. Wilke, J., et al. (2016). What Is Evidence-Based About Myofascial Chains: A Systematic Review. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, 97(3), 454–461.


Photo from BioMechanial Riding by Nancy Nicholson PhD


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page